Skip to content
Indonesian Scientific Journal

Peer Review Process

Peer Review Process

Abdiformatika: Jurnal Pengabdian Masyarakat Informatika

Abdiformatika evaluates submitted manuscripts for disciplinary relevance, originality, sound methods, research ethics, and the strength of their contribution to community-service initiatives involving informatics, information and communication technology (ICT), applied science, and technology-based community empowerment. Peer review assists the editorial decision but does not guarantee publication.

Policy at a Glance

  • Review approach: single-blind peer review by at least two anonymous reviewers
  • Decision criterion: Scientific quality and ethical compliance

1. Editorial Screening

An editor checks whether a manuscript fits the journal scope, uses an appropriate reporting structure, follows the official submission instructions, and gives sufficient evidence regarding the implemented ICT intervention, the needs of community partners, participation and implementation procedures, and documented community benefits. Manuscripts may be returned for correction or declined before external review.

2. Independent Review

Manuscripts passing screening undergo single-blind peer review by at least two anonymous reviewers. Reviewers remain anonymous to authors under this model.

Reviewers assess originality, methodological rigor, appropriateness of the evidence, clarity of presentation, ethical considerations, and the practical or scholarly value of the findings.

3. Editorial Evaluation and Revisions

Reviewer comments are considered by the editor, who may request revisions, recommend additional review, or decide that the manuscript does not meet the journal standards. Authors should respond to substantial comments and identify the changes made.

The number of revision cycles and length of evaluation depend on the nature of the manuscript and reviewer availability. No fixed number of review rounds is promised by this policy.

4. Decisions and Independence

The responsible editor communicates the outcome, which may be acceptance, revision, or rejection. Fees and requests for expedited processing must not determine scientific judgments. Editors and reviewers must disclose relevant conflicts of interest.

5. Confidentiality and Appeals

Unpublished manuscripts and reviewer assessments are confidential editorial materials. Authors who consider that a material procedural error occurred may provide a reasoned enquiry to the Editorial Office for consideration.

Contact and Further Information

For questions concerning this policy or its application to a specific manuscript, please contact the journal through its official editorial channels.

Journal: Abdiformatika: Jurnal Pengabdian Masyarakat Informatika

Publisher: Indonesian Scientific Journal (Jurnal Ilmiah Indonesia)

Contact: Official journal contact page

Submissions: Online submission system